(CMI) Interspecific Genocide

The Fascist Ideology Behind Animal Exploitation

It's Time to End Humanity's Largest Act of Violence

When Empire Trumps Peace

https://open.substack.com/pub/jonathancook/p/yes-trump-is-vulgar-but-the-us-global?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android&r=2u4ecr

https://open.substack.com/pub/councilestatemedia/p/here-is-everything-that-neoliberals?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android&r=2u4ecr

(L&CR; CMI) Giving animals their due: the argument from "marginal cases"

 05_Tanner.indd (environmentandsociety.org)

Two versions of the AMC:

Reductio ad absurdum version:

1. In order for an entity to acquire basic moral status – to matter morally, to be one toward whom we have direct moral duties -- it must possess capacity C (for example, language, or moral agency, or a complex sense of self, etc.).

2. Nonhuman animals do not possess C.

Therefore,

3. Nonhuman animals do not matter morally.

But,

4. Some humans (infants, young children, the mentally impaired, etc.) do not possess C.

Therefore,

5. Some humans do not matter morally.  (An “absurd” result.)

Formal contradiction version:

1. In order for an entity to acquire basic moral status – to matter morally, to be one toward whom we have direct moral duties -- it must possess capacity C (for example, language, or moral agency, or a complex sense of self, etc.).

2. Nonhuman animals do not possess C.

Therefore,

3. Nonhuman animals do not matter morally.

But,

4. Some humans (infants, young children, the mentally impaired, etc.) do not possess C, and

5. All humans matter morally.

Therefore,

6. It is not the case that, in order for an entity to acquire basic moral status – to matter morally, to be one toward whom we have direct moral duties -- it must possess capacity C (for example, language, or moral agency, or a complex sense of self, etc.).  (That is, (1) is false.)

(It may be, for example, that basic moral status accrues to those who can suffer, are sentient, or experience pleasure/pain)

(AP) What "is" is

The "is" of identity:

A cat is a mammal.

The "is" of simple predication:

The cat is on the mat.

The "is" of (Clintonian) existential predication:

There is no affair.

The "is" of moral judgment:

War is evil.

The "is" of artistic identification:

That upside-down tree is a work of art.

See also Sherri Irvin's critical commentary on Danto's "is of artistic identification/constitution."

(AP) Tolstoy on Art

Here's a page of art quotations from Tolstoy. One example:

To say that a work of art is good, but incomprehensible to the majority of men, is the same as saying of some kind of food that it is very good but that most people can't eat it.

What is Philosophy?

A great online "tour" of philosophy, its value, subfields, and applications from Ohio Northern University. An excerpt:


Philosophy is the systematic study of ideas and issues, a reasoned pursuit of fundamental truths, a quest for a comprehensive understanding of the world, a study of principles of conduct, and much more. Every domain of human existence raises questions to which its techniques and theories apply, and its methods may be used in the study of any subject or the pursuit of any vocation. Indeed, philosophy is in a sense inescapable: life confronts every thoughtful person with some philosophical questions, and nearly everyone is often guided by philosophical assumptions, even if unconsciously. One need not be unprepared. To a large extent one can choose how reflective one will be in clarifying and developing one's philosophical assumptions, and how well prepared one is for the philosophical questions life presents. Philosophical training enhances our problem-solving capacities, our abilities to understand and express ideas, and our persuasive powers. It also develops understanding and enjoyment of things whose absence impoverishes many lives: such things as aesthetic experience, communication with many different kinds of people, lively discussion of current issues, the discerning observation of human behavior, and intellectual zest. In these and other ways the study of philosophy contributes immeasurably in both academic and other pursuits.

The problem-solving, analytical,judgment, and synthesizing capacities philosophy develops are unrestricted in their scope and unlimited in their usefulness. This makes philosophy especially good preparation for positions of leadership, responsibility, or management. A major or minor in philosophy can easily be integrated with requirements for nearly any entry-level job; but philosophical training, particularly in its development of many transferable skills, is especially significant for its long-term benefits in career advancement.

Wisdom, leadership, and the capacity to resolve human conflicts cannot be guaranteed by any course of study; but philosophy has traditionally pursued these ideals systematically, and its methods, its literature, and its ideas are of constant use in the quest to realize them. Sound reasoning, critical thinking, well constructed prose, maturity of judgment, a strong sense of relevance, and an enlightened consciousness are never obsolete, nor are they subject to the fluctuating demands of the marketplace. The study of philosophy is the most direct route, and in many cases the only route, to the full development of these qualities.

-----------

I also appreciate these comments from Anthony Quinton, suggesting (to me, at least) that philosophy is a refinement and extension of critical thinking:

Most definitions of philosophy are fairly controversial, particularly if they aim to be at all interesting or profound. That is partly because what has been called philosophy has changed radically in scope in the course of history, with many inquiries that were originally part of it having detached themselves from it. The shortest definition, and it is quite a good one, is that philosophy is thinking about thinking. That brings out the generally second-order character of the subject, as reflective thought about particular kinds of thinking — formation of beliefs, claims to knowledge — about the world or large parts of it. A more detailed, but still uncontroversial comprehensive, definition is that philosophy is rationally critical thinking, of a more or less systematic kind about the general nature of the world (metaphysics or theory of existence), the justification of belief (epistemology or theory of knowledge), and and the conduct of life (ethics or theory of value).

New Semester

To all of my spring, 2025 seminarians: Welcome/welcome back to MCLA. Classes officially begin tomorrow, Wednesday, January 22. I have listed (in the left margin of this page) all of my spring syllabi, ancillary handouts, and dedicated "assignments" link to each course.

Environmentalism and pacifism entail veganism

Environmentalism-veganism connection:

https://open.substack.com/pub/veganhorizon/p/environmentalist-and-not-vegan-are?

Non-violence/pacifism-veganism connection:

https://veganhorizon.substack.com/p/end-the-largest-act-of-violence